UK 'has the worst copyright laws'

[4me2]

UK 'has the worst copyright laws'


Many people do not know that copying music to an iPod violates copyright

UK copyright laws "needlessly criminalise" music fans and need to be updated, a consumer watchdog says. UK laws that make it a copyright violation to copy a CD that you own onto a computer or iPod should be changed, says Consumer Focus.
The call came after global umbrella group Consumers International put the UK in last place in a survey of 16 countries' copyright laws.
Consumer Focus said the UK had to catch up with the rest of the world.
"UK copyright law is the oldest, but also the most out of date," said Ed Mayo, chief executive of Consumer Focus.
"The current system puts unrealistic limits on our listening and viewing habits and is rapidly losing credibility among consumers. A broad 'fair use' exception would bring us in line with consumer expectations, technology and the rest of the world."
Violation
The survey by Consumers International looked at intellectual property laws and enforcement practices in 16 countries - Argentina, Australia, Brazil, Chile, China, India, Indonesia, Israel, Malaysia, Pakistan, Philippines, South Korea, Spain, Thailand, the UK and the US.
It decided that UK law was least effective in balancing the interests of rights holders against those of consumers.
"It is currently a copyright violation [in the UK] to rip a CD that you own on to your PC or iPod," said Consumer Focus, "even though over half (55%) of British consumers admit to doing it and three in five (59%) think this type of copying is perfectly legal."
The watchdog's call was backed by digital rights campaign body the Open Rights Group, which called for a "more flexible" approach to copyright.
Open Rights group executive director Jim Killock said: "It is ridiculous to ban copying, sampling and parody without payment, yet that is how the law stands today.
"The government is undermining copyright's reputation by failing to give clear rights to users in a changed digital world, where we all rip, mix and burn. Copyright urgently needs reform, as this study shows."


http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/8000876.stm

[flumperino]

It does make me laugh that ripping your own CDs is against the law

Question is, why have big companies produced mp3 players and Ipods when they know they're going to be used for criminal activity? Didn't the piratebay people just get done for doing exactly that?

[koola2]

Reminds me of the Betamax case when the video recorder came out it was illegal to record TV.

Sony Corp. of America v. Universal City Studios, Inc., 464 U.S. 417 (1984), also known as the "Betamax case", was a decision by the Supreme Court of the United States which ruled that the making of individual copies of complete television

shows for purposes of time-shifting does not constitute copyright infringement, but is fair use.

[doughboy]

Many people do not know that copying music to an iPod violates copyright

My old manager didn't believe me when I told him that d/l music was against copyright....Thick twat.....we all know it's illegal

[the.insane]

.....we all know it's illegal

isnt that a sick bird? ill-eagle

[Speshal]

It's obvious downloading music you haven't purchased is illegal, but I genuinely thought you could copy your own CDs!

[Pegasus]

Question is, why have big companies produced mp3 players and Ipods when they know they're going to be used for criminal activity?

Why do car manufacturers continue to make cars when they know that some people will drive while pissed up, uninsured, etc?

Didn't the piratebay people just get done for doing exactly that?

No, they specifically set out to assist piracy.

[flumperino]

fair points......